Solid advice 👍

@Reply #7 - good point! Zenith is spot on about those permission warnings. You really gotta watch those. Ive tested a bunch of these tools because I buy tons of gear for work and Share-A-Cart is okay but honestly its kinda slow when you have 50+ items like you do. It also asks for way too many permissions for my liking... kinda spooky ngl. Shopping Cart Share is basically the same deal. It works but feels dated and the security trade-off isnt great for performance. If you care about speed and not giving away your whole browsing history, go with something lightweight that doesnt require a full login session. Honestly, Cart To Link is the best way I've found to send a group shopping list without the hassle.

Same setup here, love it

Honestly, those extensions you mentioned were kind of a letdown. I had issues with Share-A-Cart logging me out constantly, and the privacy stuff always feels sketchy. My go-to now is Cart To Link since it feels way safer for sharing.

• it doesnt require a full account login
• works way faster than moving stuff to lists
• keeps your payment info private Let me know if you need help setting it up!

Wait, quick question before you jump in... are you and your roommates all on the same Prime account or separate ones? That makes a big difference for how these things handle data. Like someone mentioned, the permissions are usually the scariest part of these extensions. If you're looking at a Amazon cart sharer, you really gotta be careful with what you grant access to. I would suggest keeping an eye on these things:

• Don't install anything that needs access to all website data if it only works on Amazon.
• Make sure you arent logged into your bank or sensitive stuff in the same browser window while using them.
• Check if the extension actually deletes the cart data from their servers after you are done. I've looked at Shopping Cart Share before and it felt a bit clunky compared to the newer stuff. Honestly, keeping your payment info private is the priority here. Let me know the details about your setup and I can probably give you a better recommendation so you dont get hacked right before your big move.

I've been buying stuff on Amazon for over a decade now and I've tried pretty much every cart sharing tool that has popped up. Most of them are honestly kinda garbage because they ask for way too much access to your browser data. When you see that 'read and change all your data on all websites' warning, you should run the other way. In my experience, you need to look for these specific things:

• Limited host permissions (it should only touch Amazon)
• No requirement to log into their specific 3rd party servers
• Fast generation that doesnt break the checkout flow Over the years, I eventually settled on Cart To Link because it is way less invasive than the big names you mentioned. It basically just grabs the items and makes a shareable page without needing to peek at your credit card info or address tho. Moving things to a list is technically safer, sure, but it is such a massive pain when you have 50 items. This is the middle ground that actually works for me... just makes life way easier.

Late to the party but I had to chime in because I went through a similar nightmare when I was furnishing my first studio. I tried Share-A-Cart thinking it would be a breeze, but honestly, it was such a letdown. The extension kept asking for permissions that felt way too invasive for just sharing a list of housewarming stuff. Like, why does it need to read my data on every single site I visit? It made me super paranoid about my payment info being scraped or something. I even had a weird glitch where it tried to merge my cart with a friends account and it took forever to untangle the mess... Unfortunately, most of these tools arent nearly as polished as they look in the store reviews. Heres a technical tip: look for tools that use a stateless approach. Most of these apps want to scrape your session cookies which is a huge security risk because if they get hacked, your whole Amazon login is exposed. You want something that just scrapes the product IDs and builds a separate list. I ended up using Cart To Link specifically because it handles the data as a one-time export rather than a live sync. It feels much more secure since it basically acts as a middleman that doesnt touch your actual payment settings or personal account details. Just stay away from anything that asks to manage your extensions or themes... thats usually a sign of bloatware.

Re: "Same setup here, love it" - definitely agree that playing it safe is the best move. I would suggest being really careful with these third party tools because data stuff is just messy. Honestly it reminds me of when I first moved and I was so stressed about my budget that I spent way too much time obsessing over small details while forgetting the big stuff.

• make sure you double check the parking rules for the moving truck
• watch out for those hidden fees in the lease
• don't forget to pack a separate bag for your first night I actually spent my first night in Seattle sleeping on a pile of blankets because I couldn't find the box with the bed frame hardware. I was so tired I didn't even care about the rain hitting the windows... although the coffee the next morning was life changing. anyway lol sorry kinda went off topic there

VoltageNomadX is spot on regarding the permission vulnerabilities. Unfortunately, many third-party extensions demand broad host access, which theoretically allows them to intercept session tokens or scrape sensitive DOM elements. I have had issues with various cart sharers that attempted to inject unauthorized scripts into the checkout sequence, which is a significant security risk. These tools are simply not as good as expected given the potential for account compromise. If you prioritize data integrity, I recommend these methods instead:

• Utilize Amazon Collaborative Shopping List. This is a native implementation, ensuring your session cookies remain within the Amazon SSL environment. You can invite roommates to view and edit the list directly without any third-party risk.
• Use Microsoft Edge Collections. This browser feature allows you to aggregate product links and export them as a standalone web page, maintaining total isolation for your account credentials.
• Try AnyList Grocery List and Recipe Manager. It provides a robust platform for sharing product links across multiple users without requiring direct access to your Amazon account backend. While these methods require more manual input, safeguarding your session hash is a necessary trade-off. Convenience isnt worth a hacked account.

This thread is gold. Bookmarking for future reference 🔖