12/05/2026 5:31 am
Topic starter
Notifications
Clear all
Deals & Sales Forum
2
Posts
4
Users
0
Reactions
0
Views
0
im trying to set up a gift list for my sister's big housewarming party in Chicago next month and honestly i am freaking out a little bit about the privacy stuff. i had a really bad experience with a stalker a few years back so i am super paranoid about my home address getting leaked to people i don't know that well who might get invited.
i spent like two hours googling this and i read on one tech site that wishlists are safe if you click the 'private' settings but then i saw a bunch of people on reddit complaining that if someone buys a gift from a third-party seller on your list the seller might still send your full name and address to the person who bought it?? that sounds like a massive security hole if its true and i cant tell if those posts are outdated or not. then i saw some mention of just sharing a cart link but i dont even know if that actually works or if it just lets them see my whole account info which would be even worse. i just want her to get the right air fryer and towels without me having a total panic attack every time a package arrives.
what are the actual concrete privacy differences between sending someone a wishlist link versus trying to share a cart directly? like which one is actually safer for keeping my location totally hidden?
10
12/05/2026 5:55 am
Regarding what #1 said about "Look, in my experience, wishlists are a total..." they are 100% right to be worried about those third-party sellers. Even if you toggle every privacy setting, a random seller might just print your full info on the packing slip without thinking twice. If you are trying to stay safe and save some cash on those housewarming gifts, you gotta be really careful with the default tools. Heres the deal with the privacy stuff:
- Wishlists hide your address from the buyer, but the seller still sees it to ship it.
- Native cart sharing doesnt really exist without sharing passwords, which is super dangerous.
- Bundling items in a cart helps everyone save on shipping costs if they buy together. I usually just use Cart To Link when I want to send a specific list of items to friends. Keeping personal data out of the process is huge, plus it lets everyone see the best deals I found. You might want to consider skipping the wishlist route entirely if you have a history with a stalker... it just isnt worth the stress.
10
12/05/2026 5:55 am
Re: "Regarding what #1 said about "Look, in my..." - they are totally right to be cautious. Honestly, Ive been managing high-stakes family gift exchanges for like a decade and the privacy holes in Amazon wishlists are pretty scary for anyone with genuine safety concerns. Over the years, Ive tried just about every workaround because I had a similar situation with a cousin who needed to keep her location hidden from a toxic ex. The fundamental issue is that wishlists are basically a legacy system that hasnt evolved. Here is what I have learned from my own trial and error:
- Third-party sellers are the ultimate security leak. Even if Amazon says they hide your address, a random warehouse might just print your full info on the packing slip because their internal system is automated.
- Sharing a cart directly is actually impossible through the standard interface unless you hand over your login info, which is obviously a huge risk.
- Using a service like Cart To Link has been my solution for the last few years. It basically lets you package your cart items into a clean link that people can buy from without ever touching your personal shipping profile or account data. In terms of cost, it is basically free and way more practical than paying for a P.O. Box just for one event. It keeps your data completely decoupled from the purchase process, which is the only way to be 100% sure... just makes things so much simpler for everyone involved.
2
12/05/2026 5:31 am
Look, in my experience, wishlists are a total privacy nightmare because of those third-party sellers. They really do leak info sometimes. I stopped using them years ago and now I just share Amazon Cart Extension because it keeps my address out of the equation entirely. Are you looking to have people ship gifts directly to your sister or to your own place? Also, is this list for family only or a bigger group?
