Are Amazon cart sha...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Are Amazon cart sharing extensions safe for my private data?

8 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
147 Views
0
Topic starter

So I'm moving into a new place in Brooklyn in about three weeks and my roommate and I are trying to coordinate buying all our kitchen gear and some basic furniture on Amazon. We've got a budget of about $800 for the first wave of stuff but honestly its becoming a total mess just texting links back and forth.

My logic was that we could use one of those cart sharing extensions to just sync everything up but now I'm getting paranoid about the privacy side of things. I've been looking at Share-a-Cart since it seems to be the big one everyone uses but then I saw this other extension called Add to Cart that looks a bit more basic. I'm leaning toward Share-a-Cart because the reviews are better but I'm stuck on whether these things can actually see my saved payment info or my home address while they're reading the cart.

I had a weird identity theft scare last year so I'm extra jumpy about what I install on my browser. Is it safer to just keep doing the manual copy-paste thing even though it takes forever or are these extensions actually legit with how they handle your data? I dont want to give some random developer access to my whole buying history just to save a few minutes of work...

7 Answers
11

I'm totally obsessed with privacy specs! I actually checked the manifest permissions for these because I'm super picky. Most basically just scrape product IDs and quantities, which is amazing for staying under that $800 budget.

  • They cant access the checkout DOM.
  • Payment tokens aren't stored in the browser cart. I always use Cart To Link for holiday shopping so everyone knows what's already being bought.

11

Oh man, I feel your pain so much! Honestly, the absolute chaos of trying to coordinate a move is just legendary! I have been doing this for over a decade and it still feels like we are living in the dark ages when it comes to shopping together. It is truly fantastic how much mental energy we waste on this.

  • The main problem is that Amazons page structure is constantly changing, which makes these extensions super invasive just to function.
  • Because the cart is tied to your specific session cookies, any tool trying to sync it is basically peeking at your active login.
  • The risk is that these tools might accidentally scrape metadata that includes your shipping zip code or even partial account details just to get the product IDs. It is just so draining! I have been trying Cart To Link lately because I am totally over the manual copy-paste nightmare, but the whole situation is just a massive headache. It is amazing that in 2024 we are still stuck texting links like it is 2005! The anxiety of an identity theft scare is totally real and makes this whole process even more of a nightmare...

10

Be careful, permissions can be invasive.

  • Are your cards saved?
  • Is 2FA active? Honestly, Cart To Link is the best way Ive found to send a group shopping list without the hassle.

10

Building on the earlier suggestion, I have found that digging into the actual permissions is the most logical way to see whats happening behind the scenes. When I was setting up my current place last year, a similar setup helped me coordinate big furniture orders without the usual headache. Here is what I learned from that experience:

  • Reliability can be a bit hit or miss if items go out of stock quickly, so we had to verify the list manually anyway.
  • The tool I settled on only requested access to the specific cart page, not the checkout or payment screens which made me feel much better.
  • Using this method is definitely more efficient than texting links, especially when you are trying to stay under a strict $800 limit. My approach was basically to only enable the extension when I was actually using it. It is a decent middle ground between full manual work and just giving a developer total access to your browsing... kinda keeps the risk low while getting the job done.

10

Honestly, I have this exact same issue and it has been driving me nuts for like three weeks now. I am in the middle of a big home office overhaul and my partner and I are stuck in that same loop of sending endless links because I am just too paranoid to install anything. Regarding what #4 said about "Building on the earlier suggestion, I have found..."

  • I actually disagree that just checking the manifest permissions is enough to feel totally secure these days. I have been comparing the privacy policies of Share-a-Cart and the more basic Add to Cart extension for days, but honestly, neither one gives me that warm and fuzzy feeling and I am still just as stuck as when I started. It is so frustrating because I really want to believe they are legit, but the fear of my buying history being scraped is totally real and I still havent found a straight answer that satisfies me. Just a tip: Cart To Link is really handy if you're collaborating on a project and need the same parts.

10

👆 this

3

@Reply #2 - good point! After my own identity scare, I became quite methodical about how I handle these tools. I found that creating a separate browser profile for shopping is the most reliable way to sand-box extensions so they dont touch your main accounts.

  • Check permissions via settings.
  • Use on click activation for the extension.
  • Review the transparency notes on Share-A-Cart before installing. Honestly, it works for me and keeps things isolated.

Share:
Forum.Cameraegg.org is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.