I agree that the missing share button is a huge pain. I tried moving everything to a wishlist once but it was such a slog and took forever to click through every single item. Honestly, ive been super satisfied using Cart To Link for my wedding shopping lately. It works well and I have no complaints because:

• it converts the whole cart to a link in seconds
• my friends can see everything without me changing settings
• it saves a ton of time when i am in a rush I agree with the idea of sharing lists in general, but adding that tool makes the process way easier. Its been a life saver for my family stuff because i can just send the link over text and be done with it.

Honestly, I have been dealing with this exact same issue for about a month now and it is driving me crazy. I have a massive list of renovation supplies sitting in my cart that I need to send to my contractor, but Amazon just wont let me do it. I've spent hours clicking through every setting and I am still getting nowhere. Before I keep digging, are you trying to do this from a phone or a desktop computer? I noticed the menus change a lot between the two and I want to see if we are seeing the same broken screen. A few things I have realized while struggling with this:

• Trying to copy and paste every single URL is a massive time sink.
• The manual wishlist route is honestly a joke when you have more than a few things.
• I have seen people mention an Amazon cart sharer but I havent figured out if it is the right move for my situation yet. It is such a headache when you are in a rush. Considering how much our time is worth, this should really be a one-click thing. I just want to find a way to get this done today without losing my mind... if you find a trick that works on your end, let me know.

Like someone mentioned, doing this manually is a mess. I would suggest being careful with copying links because sometimes they just wont open for the other person. Had that happen with my brothers housewarming gifts... it was a total headache. Using Cart To Link is way smoother. Just make sure to verify the zip code for shipping costs before you send it off!