So I finally made the jump from my old full frame DSLR setup to the Fujifilm X-T5 and man my back is already thanking me but I am hitting a bit of a wall with the glass situation. I am used to those heavy Sigma Art lenses on my old Canon and I really love that clinical sharpness but also that specific rendering they have so naturally I am looking at the Sigma X-mount options for a big trip I have coming up to the Dolomites in late September. I really want to travel light this time because we are doing a lot of hiking but I am worried about the 40 megapixel sensor on the X-T5 and if some of these smaller lenses can actually keep up with it.
I have been looking really hard at the Sigma 18-50mm f2.8 because it is just so tiny and would be a dream for packing but then I keep thinking about the 23mm f1.4 or even the 33mm. I usually shoot landscapes and some street stuff when we stop in the mountain villages so I need something versatile. My budget is capped at about 600 bucks since I spent way too much on the body and some extra batteries already.
The issue is I have heard mixed things about the 18-50 on the high res sensor vs the primes. Is the zoom sharp enough for those big landscape prints or am I gonna regret not having a fast prime for when the light gets low in the valleys? I used to be a prime-only shooter but the convenience of that tiny zoom is really calling my name for this specific trip. Does the 18-50 feel balanced on the X-T5 or is it almost too small? I am also wondering if the lack of an aperture ring on the Sigma lenses is actually a dealbreaker for most Fuji shooters since that is half the fun of the system... been going back and forth on this for weeks now.
If anyone has used these specifically on the X-T5 for a one-lens travel kit I would love to know which one actually lives on your camera most of the time or if you find yourself constantly wishing you had brought something else...
Unfortunately, the Sigma 18-50mm f2.8 DC DN Contemporary had issues resolving detail on that sensor. The Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Contemporary is technically superior but isn't as versatile. What print sizes are you actually targeting?
Been thinking about your question for a bit and honestly, you might want to be careful with that 40MP sensor. It really pushes glass to its limit. If you are planning on doing those big landscape prints for the Dolomites, the zoom might show some softness in the corners that you wouldnt see on an older body. I would suggest keeping a few things in mind before you pull the trigger: