I really need to know which Sigma lens is actually the best for an X-T5 when shooting street at night because I am getting so many conflicting answers online and it is driving me crazy.
I've been looking at the Sigma 18-50mm f2.8 since everyone says it is the perfect small lens for the Fuji system and the size is great for being discreet but then I see people saying f2.8 just isnt enough when you are in dark back alleys or shooting under neon signs where the shadows are super deep. I am heading to Tokyo in about three weeks so I am on a tight timeline to get this sorted and I really want to capture that blade runner vibe without my ISO hitting 12800 and making everything look like mush.
Then I looked at the Sigma 30mm f1.4 which is way faster but then I read some forums saying the autofocus is kinda hunt-y on the X-T5 specifically or that it is not as sharp as the newer Fuji primes. But the Fuji primes are way out of my budget right now since I can only spend about 500 bucks max after buying the camera body itself. I also looked at the 16mm f1.4 but that seems way too wide for street stuff unless I want to be shoved in peoples faces which I really dont want to do.
I am just frustrated because I want that Sigma value but I cant tell if:
I just want something that wont weigh me down while I am walking 20,000 steps a day but can actually handle the low light without looking terrible. Every review video I watch just shows beautiful sunny day shots which helps me exactly zero percent for what I actually need for this trip. The X-T5 is amazing but if I cant find a lens that works in the dark for under 500 dollars I am gonna be so annoyed...
Honestly, Tokyo at night is a total light hog. I would suggest being pretty careful with the Sigma 18-50mm f2.8 DC DN Contemporary Fuji X because even with IBIS, that f/2.8 aperture might force your ISO way higher than you'd like when subjects are moving. That 40MP sensor on the X-T5 is pretty unforgiving with noise once you push it. Heres the deal for your trip:
^ This. Also, speed is everything in those Golden Gai alleys! I grabbed the Sigma 23mm f1.4 DC DN Contemporary Fuji X right before my last Osaka trip and it was a total lifesaver. The AF is way snappier than the older 30mm tho. Pro tip: grab it used to stay under that 500 dollar limit. Honestly, f1.4 makes those neon signs pop like crazy and it wont let you down!
Re: Tokyo light being a hog. My fast setup saved me in Shinjuku last year.