Man, I totally feel your pain! Nothing is worse than feeling your expensive gear wiggle around in a cheap piece of leather. Ive spent way too much money testing these out and honestly, most of them are garbage. If you want something that actually stays put and protects your X-T5 during a hectic street session, you need to look at these two:

• Get yourself the Gariz Design Genuine Leather Half Case for Fujifilm X-T5. Seriously, this thing is a beast! It has a solid metal baseplate built right into the leather which is a total game changer. It keeps the shape perfectly and doesnt sag or stretch out even after months of heavy use. I have banged mine against brick walls in the city and it barely has a scratch.
• Another fantastic choice is the Kaza Deluxe Leather Half Case for Fujifilm X-T5 Vintage Brown. They hand-make these and the fit is incredibly snug... like, you actually have to work a bit to get it on because the tolerances are so tight. Quick tip: always look for cases with a screw-in attachment rather than just a snap-on. It makes the whole setup feel like one solid unit instead of a camera sitting in a bucket. You wont regret spending a bit extra for the peace of mind! It basically turns the camera into a tank... definitely worth every penny for the protection alone.

I used a cheap sleeve on my last trip and the camera actually slipped out. Heart attack material. I eventually realized base rigidity is what actually matters for protection. I switched to the JB Camera Designs Wood and Leather Pro Shield for Fujifilm X-T5 and it works well. It stays snug. The wood base protects the bottom better, though its bulkier. TL;DR: Hybrid cases with wood bases offer more impact protection.

Honestly, its so frustrating when you spend good money and the leather starts stretching out after a few weeks. I had issues with those generic brands too... they just end up feeling like a soggy glove and actually make the camera harder to hold. Nearly dropping an X-T5 in the Loop sounds like a total nightmare, id be shaking too. For the X-T5, you really should look at Lim's Design Genuine Leather Half Case for Fujifilm X-T5 with Aluminum Base. I picked one up after a bad experience with a case that basically warped in the humidity. The big difference here is the milled aluminum base plate. It keeps the bottom of the camera totally rigid and flat, which stops that annoying wiggle youre dealing with now. Plus, it has a built-in Arca-Swiss dovetail so you can pop it onto a tripod instantly without messing with extra plates. If you want something a bit simpler, TP Original Leather Half Case for Fujifilm X-T5 Wax Brown is a solid runner-up. Its a bit more traditional and fits the budget perfectly. It doesnt have the fancy metal frame of the Lims, but the leather is way thicker than the cheap knockoffs. Unfortunately, most brands just prioritize looks over build quality lately, but these two actually hold their shape over time. Let me know if you have questions about the grip feel!

Honestly its ridiculous how the quality of these accessories has gone downhill lately while the prices just keep climbing. It drives me crazy that we pay over a hundred bucks for something thats basically a glorified sock for a two-thousand dollar camera. I have had issues with so many brands where the leather just stretches out until its basically useless. Its such a scam that they market these for pro use when they barely survive a weekend trip.

• the leather is usually way too thin to absorb any actual impact
• the glue they use starts peeling as soon as it gets slightly humid
• most of these companies just dont care about long-term durability anymore It really is a nightmare nearly dropping your gear like that tho, honestly had my heart sink just reading it. Before I give you my picks for what actually stays tight, are you mainly looking for something that covers the corners for drop protection, or is the loose grip the biggest deal breaker for you?

Nice, didn't know that